TENSIONS BETWEEN THEORY AND HISTORY IN VON MISES'S CRITIQUE OF SOCIALISM

Authors

  • Emmanoel Boff Universidade Federal Fluminense (UFF)

Keywords:

Mises, socialism, socialist calculation, critique

Abstract

The article investigates the relation between praxeology and history in the critique Mises directs at the possibility of the long-term existence of a socialist commonwealth. We argue that Mises makes no clear distinction between the praxeological concept of 'private property' (associated with the possession of means of production) and the historical concept of the ideal-type 'private property' (associated to property rights -- see HODGSON, 2015). The lack of precision between the theoretical and the historical concepts of private property prevents Mises's critique from being an 'exact law', as he would have it. Finally, we show in the last section the consequences for Mises's critique of socialism of having a historical and a praxeological concept of private property. 

Downloads

Published

2018-08-28

Issue

Rev. Econ. Contemp., v. 22, n. 2, mai./ago. 2018

Section

Artigos

License

The Revista de Economia Contemporânea (Journal of Contemporary Economics) adopted the Creative Commons license attribution-type BY-NC until April/2015. The license attribution-type BY has been adopted ever since.

Ownership of copyrights belongs to the IE-UFRJ (Instituto de Economia da UFRJ), which will not pay copyrights for published works. In accordance with current copyright regulation and the type of copyright license adopted (CC-BY), article full or partial reproduction and release are allowed provided that the citation source is disclosed. In case this copyright rule is not obliged, a written warning will be issued by the publisher to the person who has disregarded this regulation.