Comparative Law and Decolonizing Critique

Sherally Munshi

Resumo


ABSTRACT:

This essay asserts that comparative legal scholarship might overcome its current crisis of relevance by reorienting itself towards decolonizing critique. In a recent article, decrying the current state of the discipline, Pierre Legrand argued that comparative law has become mired in a solipsistic and outmoded style of positivism. Draying upon insights from critical theory, he argues that the discipline might render itself more relevant by engaging in a more contextualized analyses of the law and by encouraging active interpretation beyond descriptive reporting. This essay extends Legrand’s argument to suggest that an emancipated, incorporative, and interdisciplinary comparative law might play an important role in decolonizing legal scholarship more broadly. Founded in a commitment to constrain an ethnocentric impulse in legal discourse, comparative law seems a natural site from which to challenge the varieties of Eurocentrism that continue to define legal scholarship and study and for exploring the colonial roots of globalized racial formations. 

RESUMO:

Este ensaio propõe que os estudos jurídicos comparados podem superar sua atual crise de relevância reorientando-se para a crítica decolonial. Em artigo recente, condenando o estado atual da disciplina, Pierre Legrand argumentou que o direito comparado está atolado em um estilo solipsista e ultrapassado do positivismo. Refletindo sobre os insights da teoria crítica, ele argumenta que a disciplina pode tornar-se mais relevante envolvendo-se em uma análise mais contextualizada da lei e incentivando a interpretação ativa para além de relatórios descritivos. Este ensaio amplia o argumento de Legrand para sugerir que um direito comparado emancipado, incorporativo e interdisciplinar pode desempenhar um papel importante na decolonização mais ampla da doutrina jurídica. Fundado em um compromisso de restringir um impulso etnocêntrico no discurso legal, o direito comparado parece um local natural a partir do qual é possível desafiar as variedades do Eurocentrismo que continuam a definir a doutrina e a produção acadêmica jurídica e a explorar as raízes coloniais das formações raciais globalizadas. 


Palavras-chave


Comparative Law; Decolonizing Critique; Pierre Legrand; Critical Theory; Direito Comparado; Crítica Decolonial; Pierre Legrand; Teoria Crítica

Texto completo:

PDF (English)

Referências


AM. COMPARATIVE LITERATURE ASS’N, ACLA Report on the State of the Discipline 2014–2015 (Ursula Heise et al. eds., 2015), stateofthediscipline.acla.org

AKBAR, Amna A., Law’s Exposure: The Movement and the Legal Academy, 65 J. of Legal Ed. 352, 355 (2015).

ARENDT, Hannah. The Human Condition (2d ed. 1998).

BAILEY, Phillip M. Confederate Memorial at U of L to be Removed, COURIER-J. (Apr. 29, 2016), http://www.courier-journal. com/story/news/local/2016/04/29/ramsey-fischer-discussconfederate-statue/83695160/.

BALD, Vivek. Bengali Harlem And The Lost Histories Of South Asian America (2013)

BBC NEWS. Rhodes Statue Removed in Capetown as Crowd Celebrates, (Apr. 9, 2016), http://www.bbc.com/news/worldafrica-32236922.

BEHDAD, Ali & THOMAS, Dominic (eds.) A Companion To Comparative Literature (2011).

BERNHEIMER, Charles. The Anxieties of Comparison, in Comparative Literature In The Age Of Multiculturalism 1, (Charles Bernheimer ed., 1996a).

_____. The Levin Report, 1965: A Report on Professional Standards, in Comparative Literature In The Age Of Multiculturalism 1, (CHARLES BERNHEIMER ED., 1996b).

_____. The Greene Report, 1975: A Report on Standards, in Comparative Literature In The Age Of Multiculturalism 1, (CHARLES BERNHEIMER ED., 1996c). _____.

Comparative Literature at the Turn of the Century: The Bernheimer Report, 1993, in Comparative Literature In The Age Of Multiculturalism, 1, (CHARLES BERNHEIMER ED., 1996d).

BHANDAR, Brenna. Colonial Lives Of Property: Law, Land, And Racial Regimes Of Ownership (2018).

BIKO, Steve, I Write What I Like (1978).

BOSMAN, Julie. Chicago State, a Lifeline for Poor Blacks, is Under Threat Itself, N.Y. TIMES (Apr. 9, 2016), http://www.nytimes. com/2016/04/10/us/chicago-state-a-lifeline-for-poor-blacks-isunder-threat-itself.html

BROOKS, Peter. Am I a Comparatist?, in Building A Profession: Autobiographical Perspectives On The Beginnings Of

Comparative Literature In The United States 49 (Lionel Grossman & Mihai I. Spariosu eds., 1994).

BURKE, Jason. Protests to Continue at Indian University after Student Leader’s Arrest, THE GUARDIAN (Feb. 15, 2016), https:// www.theguardian.com/world/2016/feb/15/jawaharlal-nehruuniversity-kanhaiya-kumar-student-arrest-india.

BURTON, Antoinette. Africa In The Indian Imagination (2016).

CÉSAIRE, Aimé. Discourse On Colonialism (Joan Pinkham trans., 1972).

CHAN, Sewell. Black Lives Matter Activists Stage Protests Across Britain, N.Y. TIMES (Aug. 5, 2016), http://www. nytimes.com/2016/08/06/world/europe/black-lives-matterdemonstrations-britain.html.

CHAUDHURI, Amit. The Real Meaning of Rhodes Must Fall, The Guardian (Mar. 16, 2016), https://www.theguardian.com/uknews/2016/mar/16/the-real-meaning-of-rhodes-must-fall. CHOW, Rey. The Age Of The World Target: Self-Referentiality In War, Theory, And Comparative Work (2012).

COALITION STUDENTS OF COLOR GEO. U. L. CTR. From Students of Color: An Open Letter to GULC Administration, Staff, Faculty & Students, https://georgetownlawcoalition.wordpress. com/2014/12/06/an-open-letter-to-gulc-administration-stafffaculty-students/ (last visited Dec. 6, 2014).

COHEN, Mathilde. Judicial Diversity in France: The Unspoken and the Unspeakable, 43 L. & SOC. INQ. (2018).

COHN, Bernard. Law and the Colonial State in India, in Colonialism And Its Forms Of Knowledge: The British In India 57 (1996).

COLE, Simon A. Suspect Identities: A History Of Fingerprinting And Criminal Identification (2001).

COTTROL, Robert J. The Long, Lingering Shadow: Slavery, Race, And Law In The American Hemisphere (2013).

CROCKER, Lizzie. Is Yale’s English Course Really Too ‘White’? THE DAILY BEAST, http://www.thedailybeast.com/ articles/2016/06/02/is-yale-s-english-course-really-too-white. html (June 6, 2016)

DEMLEITNER, Nora V. Combating Legal Ethnocentrism: Comparative Law Sets Boundaries, 31 ARIZ. ST. L. J. 373, 737 (1999). DU BOIS, W.E.B. The Souls of Black Folk (1903). _____. Darkwater: Voices from within the Veil 23 (1999).

_____. Indians and American Negros, ca. March 1936, in Du Bois , W.E.B. Papers (Ms 312) (Special Collections Univ. Archives, Univ. Mass. Library), (1936) http://credo.library.umass.edu/view/full/ mums312-b209-i028.

_____. The Color Line Belts the World, in Du Bois , W.E.B: A Reader 42 (David Levering Lewis ed., 1st ed. 1995).

_____. The African Roots of the War, Atlantic Monthly, May 1915.

DUBLER, Ariela R. Immoral Purposes: Marriage and the Genus of Illicit Sex, 115 YALE L. J. 756 (2006).

DUVE, Thomas. Entanglements in Legal History: Introductory Remarks, in Entanglements In Legal History 7 (Thomas Duve ed., 2014).

EDWARDS, Brent Hayes. The Practice Of Diaspora: Literature, Translation, And The Rise Of Black Internationalism (2003).

FANON, Franz. Black Skin, White Masks (1952). _____. The Wretched Of The Earth (1961).

FERRIS, Davis. Why Compare? in A Companion To Comparative Literature 75, 75 (Ali Behdad & Dominic Thomas eds., 2011).

FRANKENGERG, Gunter. Critical Comparisons: Re-thinking Comparative Law, 26 HARV. INT’L L. J. 411 (1985).

FUJIKANE, Candace & OKAMURA, Jonathan Y. Asian Settler Colonialism: From Local Governance To The Habits Of Everyday Life In Hawaii (2008)

GARFIELD, Jay L. & VAN NORDEN, Bryan W. If Philosophy Won’t Diversify, Let’s Call It What it Really Is, N. Y. TIMES (May 11, 2016).

GOLDBERG, David Theo. The Comparative and the Relational: Meditations on Racial Method, in A Companion To Comparative Literature 75, 75 (Ali Behdad & Dominic Thomas eds., 2011).

GOURGOURIS, Stathis. The Poiein of Secular Criticism, in A Companion To Comparative Literature 75, 75 (Ali Behdad & Dominic Thomas eds., 2011).

GROSS, Ariela J. What Blood Won’t Tell: A History Of Race On Trial In America (2010).

GUPTA, Akhil. Beyond ‘Culture’: Space, Identity, and the Politics of Difference, 7 Cultural Anthropology 6, 6 (2008).

HALLEY, Janet. My Isaac Royall Legacy, 24 HARV. BLACKLETTER L. J. 117, 120 (2008).

HAR. L. COALITION. Letter to Dean Minow and Harvard Law School Administration. harvardlawcoalition.wordpress.com (Dec. 7, 2014).

HERNANDEZ, Tanya Kateri. Envisinoing the United States in the Latin American Myth of “Racial Democracy Mestizaje,” 11 LATIN AM. AND CARIBBEAN ETHNIC STUDIES 189-205 (2016).

HOLLIFIELD, James, MARTIN, Philip. & ORRENIUS, Pia (eds.). Controlling Immigration: A Global Perspective IX , 3rd ed. (2014).

HORNE, Gerald. The End Of Empires: African Americans And India (2008).

JASCHIK, Scott. The Law Professor Who Answered Back, INSIDE HIGHERED, https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2016/07/12/ law-professor-responds-students-who-complained-about-herblack-lives-matter-shirt (July 12, 2016).

KADIR, Djelal. To World, To Globalize: World Literature’s Crossroads, in World Literature In Theory 364 (David Damrosch ed., 2014).

KELLEY, Robin D. G. ‘But a Local Phase of a World Problem’: Black History’s Global Vision, 86 J. OF AM. HIST. 1045, 1045–51 (1999). LAKE, Marilyn. From Mississippi to Melbourne via Natal: the Invention of the Literacy Test as a Technology of Racial Exclusion, in Connected Worlds: History In Transnational Perspective 208, 216 (Ann Curthoys & Marilyn Lake eds., 2005).

LANGER, Maximo. From Legal Transplants to Legal Translations: The Globalization of Plea Bargaining and the Americanization Thesis in Criminal Procedure, 45 HARV. INT’L L. J. 1 (2004).

LEGRAND, Pierre. Jameses at Play: A Traction on the Comparison of Laws, 65 Am. J. Comp. L. (Special Issue) 1 (2017). http://www. pierre-legrand.com/jameses-at-play.pdf

LIONNET, François & SHIH, Shu-mei. Introduction: Thinking Through the Minor, Transnationally, in Minor Transnationalism (François Lionnet & Shu-mei Shih eds., 2005).

LOWE, Lisa. The Intimacies Of Four Continents (2015).

MADENGA, Tadiwa. Rhodes Legacy: From Dylan Roof to Oxford, SKIN DEEP MAG., http://www.skindeepmag.com/online-articles/rhodeslegacy-from-dylann-roof-to-oxford/ (last visited Aug. 13, 2016).

MARKESINIS, Basil S. Comparative Law In The Courtroom And The Classroom: The Story Of The Last Thirty-Five Years 50 (2003).

MARKUS, Andrew. Fear And Hatred: Purifying Australia And California, 1850–1901, XI (1979).

MAWANI, Renisa. Colonial Proximities: Crossracial Encounters And Juridical Truths In British Columbia, 1871–1921 (2009).

MBEMBE, Achille. Professor, Wits Inst. Soc. Econ. Res, WISER Public Lecture: Decolonizing Knowledge and the Question of the Archive (2015), http://wiser.wits.ac.za/system/files/Achille%20 Mbembe%20-%20Decolonizing%20Knowledge%20and%20 the%20Question%20of%20the%20Archive.pdf.

MCKINLEY, Michelle. Fractional Freedoms: Slavery, Intimacy, And Legal Mobilization In Colonial Lima, 1600-1700 (2016).

MEREDITH, Martin. Diamonds, Gold, and the War: The British, the Boers, and the Making of South Africa 127 (2008).

MOUNTZ, Allison. Seeking Asylum: Human Smuggling And Bureaucracy At The Border (2010).

MUNSHI, Sherally. ‘You Will See My Family Became So American’: Toward a Minor Comparativism, 63 AM. J. OF COMP. LAW 656, 664 (2015).

_____. Immigration, Imperialism and the Legacies of Indian Exclusion, 28 YALE J. OF L. & HUMANITIES 51 (2016).

NEUMAN, Scott. Jefferson Davis Statue Comes Down at University of Texas, NPR (Aug. 30, 2015), http://www.npr.org/sections/ thetwo-way/2015/08/30/436072805/jefferson-davis-statuecomes-down-at-university-of-texas

N. Y. TIMES. Editorial, The Case Against Woodrow Wilson, (Nov. 24, 2015), http://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/25/opinion/thecase-against-woodrow-wilson-at-princeton

NPR NEWSHOUR. How Ferguson Influenced the Student Uprising and Mizzou: Interview with Brenda Smith-Lezama of the University of Missouri Students Association, (Nov. 9, 2015), http:// www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/student-revolt-ferguson-oustedmizzoup/

PARKER, Claire E. Law School Activists Occupy Student Center, HARV. CRIMSON (Feb. 17, 2016), http://www.thecrimson.com/ article/2016/2/17/activists-occupy-wasserstein PASCOE, Peggy. What Comes Naturally: Miscegenation Law And The Making Of Race In America (2009).

PRASHAD, Vijay. The Karma Of Brown Folk (2000)

RANA, Aziz. Colonialism and Constitutional Memory, in 5 U.C. IRVINE L. REV. 263 (2015).

REIMANN, Mathias. Stepping out of the European Shadow: Why the United States Must Develop Its Own Agenda, 46 AM. J. OF COMP. LAW 637, 639 (1998).

REMNICK, Noah. Yale Grapples with Ties to Slavery in Debate Over a College’s Name, N.Y. Times (Sep. 11, 2015) http://www.nytimes. com/2015/09/12/nyregion/yale-in-debate-over-calhoun-collegegrapples-with-ties-to-slavery.

RUSKOLA, Teemu. Legal Orientalism (2013). RUSSELL POLLIT, S.J., Student Protest in South Africa: #RhodesMustFall, Am. Mag.: Nat’l Cath. Rev. (Mar. 27, 2015), http://americamagazine.org/content/dispatches/student-protestsouth-africa-rhodesmustfall. RHYS, Jean. Wide Sargasso Sea (1966).

S. AFR. HIST. ONLINE, Cecil John Rhodes, S. Afr. Hist. Online: Towards a People’s Hist. 2016 http://www.sahistory.org.za/ people/cecil-john-rhodes (last visited Aug. 13, 2016) SAID, Edward. Culture and Imperialism 43–61 (1993).

SAUSSY, Haun. Exquisite Cadavers Stitched from Fresh Nightmares: Of Memes, Hives, and Selfish Genes, in COMPARATIVE LITERATURE IN THE AGE OF GLOBALIZATION 3 (Haun Sassy ed., 2006).

SHAH, Nayan. Stranger Intimacy: Contesting Race, Sexuality, And The Law In The North American West (2011).

SIMPSON, Audra. Mohawk Interruptus: Political Life Across The Borders Of Settler States (2014).

SINHA, Manisha. The Slave’s Cause: A History Of Abolition (2016) (book jacket). SINGH, Nikhil Pal. Black Is A Country: Race And Unfinished Struggle For Democracy (2005).

SLATE, Nico. Colored Cosmopolitanism: The Struggle For Freedom In The United States And India (2012).

SPIVAK, Gayatri Chakravorty & DAMROSCH, David. Comparative Literature / World Literature: A Discussion, in World Literature In Theory 364 (David Damrosch ed., 2014).

_____. Death of a Discipline (THE WELLEK LIBRARY LECTURES) 72 (2003).

_____. Ethics and Politics in Tagore, Coetzee, and Certain Scenes of Teaching, 32:2 DIACRITICS 17, 37 (2002).

_____. Afterword to JACQUES DERRIDA, OF GRAMMATOLOGY 345 (Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak trans., 2016).

TAYLOR, Goldie. Exclusive: Bree Newsome Speaks For The First Time After Courageous Act of Civil Disobedience, BLUE NATION REV. (June 29, 2015), http://archives.bluenationreview. com/exclusive-bree-newsome-speaks-for-the-first-time-aftercourageous-act-of-civil-disobedience/ U.S.-CHINA. Burlingame-Seward Treaty, U.S.-China, July 28, 1868, 1 U.S.T.I.A. 234 (1910).

VOLPP, Leti. The Indigenous as Alien, 5 U.C. IRVINE L. REV. 289 (2015).

WA THIONG’O, Ngugi, Decolonising the Mind (1986). WELLEK, René. The Crisis of Comparative Literature, in Concepts Of Criticism (Stephen G. Nichols, Jr. ed., 1963a).

_____. The Revolt Against Positivism in Recent European Literary Scholarship, in Concepts Of Criticism (Stephen G. Nichols, Jr. ed., 1963b).

WOLIN, Richard. The Wind From The East: French Intellectuals, The Cultural Revolution, And The Legacy Of The 1960s (2012).

WOODSON, Carter G. The Miseducation of the Negro (1933).

ZAPPI, Sylvia. Rassemblement à Paris de ‘Black Lives Matter France’ aprés la mort d’Adama Traoré, LE MONDE (July 23, 2016), http://www.lemonde.fr/police-justice/article/2016/07/23/ rassemblement-a-paris-de-black-lives-matter-france-apres-lamort-d-adama-traore_4973930_1653578.html




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.21875/tjc.v2i2.12991

Apontamentos

  • Não há apontamentos.


Direitos autorais 2018 Sherally Munshi

ISSN 2526-0464

Indexada em: / Indexed by: